Improbable Press
Cart 0

What "We're Editing Your Book" Really Means

Publishing Reference

By Atlin Merrick

What "We're Editing Your Book" Really Means by Atlin Merrick

A writer recently asked what we mean by 'we're editing your book,' and though we've talked about the overall book editing process on this blog, we never covered the nitty gritty of how the editing process goes.

We're about to do that right now.

How We Edit Your Book

You've sent your completed novel to us. We've never seen those words before. We're excited!

Though the precise process depends on the editor, for Improbable Press, this is how we edit:

  • While we read, we're making note of big things like 'this story starts too early… begin the book at chapter three' or 'this scene was great, would love to see more!' or 'not sure what's happening in this scene, needs to be fleshed out.' We then send the comment-heavy manuscript back to you. (We do not let you know how it's going as we're reading; there's just not time to give you a chapter-by-chapter reaction so please be patient.)
A Short Story is a Seed: Plant as Many as You Can
How to Disagree With Your Editor
5 Ways for Shy People to Promote Their Book
  • Once you get our edits, you can agree or disagree with the changes we've asked for. If you don't agree with the big ones, we may have to end our collaboration, since we see the book differently and that's fine. Know that your book will never be changed against your will. You own it, it's yours; if we've reached an impasse you can take your book elsewhere – the original manuscript, not the one we worked on. If you do agree with most of our changes, you and the editor agree on a deadline for implementing them – and most editors are flexible, so don't get in a panic that you'll have to do a lot in a little time. Once you make the needed changes, you send the book back to us.
  • We read the book again and presuming the changes are great, we enter the copyedit phase, where we're likely to make more fine-grained edits. Maybe we tell you two characters sound a lot alike, can you tweak their dialog? Or some paragraphs are overlong, can you break them up? Again, if you agree with our suggestions, you make the changes, if you don't, we discuss why. There's more flexibility here for you to disagree, but you also want to listen to why the editor wants those changes.
  • After you've made the next set of edits, we read your book a third time and then pass it on to a proofreader. The book is fresh to their eyes so they find stuff we missed, maybe a character's name was changed and neither you or your editor realized the old name still lingers in a few spots.
  • We're almost there! Once again the book comes back to you and you look at the proofreader's edits. Sometimes, depending on your topic, we may then send the book for a sensitivity read – if your protagonist is Deaf, for example, we may have a Deaf reader look at your book and make suggestions. These are also sent to you.
  • Assuming all is well, we're done with the edits of your book! Behold its glory and rejoice!

Publishing a Book Takes Patience

Now comes the rest of the process toward publication: book layout, cover design, and your book joining the publishing queue – yes, queue, because there are always books ahead of yours waiting to be edited, proofread, laid out, cover designed, and published.

Writing Your First Novel: 5 Things You Need to Know
Why Write What You Know Also Means Write What You Don't
Super Secret Tips For Getting Your Short Story Published

The publisher may have an idea when your book will debut, but that date can change. Like films, books get reshuffled in the queue for a dozen reasons, it rarely has anything to do with your book and everything to do with Life Happens™.

Publishing requires patience, there's no quick way to be published because this is a collaboration, and there are a lot of people working on getting your book ready. You can self-pub, of course, and then the only book in the queue is yours. That's perfectly valid. But if you're working with an independent press, book publishing takes time.

Have questions about any of this? We love them, so ask them!

Older Post Newer Post

  • Atlin Merrick on

    Answering Ellie’s question:

    Hi Ellie, contracts come into play when we accept your book or story. So if you’ve sent us a completed book, before we start editing, planning on the date of publication, any of that…we send you a contract. Every publisher should, otherwise how can you know what royalty percentage you’ll get? What your publisher will do for you and requests you do for them?

    Thank you for asking and I’m more than happy to answer any other questions!


  • Ellie on

    Hi, I was wondering at what point a contract comes into play? In other words: when is the book placed with you? Or do you work without contracts at Improbable? Thanks!

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published